One
function of religious and charitable global organizations is
to bring spiritual and material relief as well as hope for a
different future to people in need. The Irish priest Leonard
O’Brien’s Children of the Sun: the Cork Mission to South
America intertwines twentieth century Peruvian history
with the Cork and Ross Irish Mission. This text tells the
history of Cork and Ross’ Catholic Mission that began in
Peru and later expanded to Ecuador and Chile. The writing is
very clear and it is organized in chronological order. It
covers the time period from the sixties up to year 2004
(when Irish mission leaves South America). The text is
organized into thirty-seven chapters that map out a variety
of social, political, economic, and cultural topics. This
provides the reader with a good general overview of Peruvian
society. The chapters are grouped together (mainly) in
sections according to particular topics (geographical
regions, material conditions, Irish mission expansions
throughout South America, etc.) and the narrative structure
varies from chapter to chapter. While some chapters begin
with an opening paragraph with a historical
contextualization, others introduce the Irish mission work,
and follow with a Peruvian socio-historical explanation.
O’Brien
portrays the crucial role the Cork and Ross mission played
in terms of education, health, and food in Trujillo, a city
in northern Peru. Catholic missions provided help through
education for children, vocational classes for women
(cooking and dressmaking classes), hospital health care
provided by nuns. Food was distributed to the needy with
funds given by Irish Catholic institutions and parishioners,
as well as by North American aid institutions such as
Caritas. O’Brien describes the material and political
conditions of marginalized barrios, depicting health
problems such as the cholera epidemic and natural disasters
such as the 1970 earthquake and El Niño in 1997/1998.
He also discusses the presence and threat of the Maoist
group Shining Path, from its beginning up to the capture of
its leader Abimael Guzmán on 12 September 1992. Shining
Path’s threat was closely felt by different religious
congregations including the Australian, Polish, and
Italian missionaries who were assassinated by Shining Path
aniquilamiento commands.
The Irish
priest’s narrative portrays how the Peruvian state’s lack of
presence in extremely poor barrios is substituted by
the Irish mission. As this narrative is written from the
viewpoint of the Catholic Church, Children of the Sun
lacks self-criticism and is largely unaware of the power
dynamics between the Church and the Peruvian state. While
one aspect of the Catholic Church’s agenda is to recruit
more people to be part of the institution, one could read
their use of the Peruvian ‘state apparatus’ with regards to
education and health care as a means of exercising their
influence over the new ‘recruits’. In a poor country like
Peru, it becomes easier to ‘evangelize’ in neglected cities
when food and health are exchanged. It is important to
mention that the traditional predominance of the Catholic
Church –within Latin America– has been challenged by other
religious institutions in the twentieth century. For this
reason, Catholic missionary work becomes an important tool
of the Catholic Church. In fact, O’Brien’s text expresses
this concern in his discussion of the ‘Protestant sects’.
O’Brien’s narrative historically
contextualizes the cultural adaptation of priests and nuns
in Peru, and shows an in-depth knowledge on his part of
Peruvian social and cultural conditions, specifically
through its portrayals of differences among various Peruvian
geographical regions, including the coast, the Andean zone,
and the jungle; however, it would have been important to
present specific information regarding various Peruvian
historical time periods. That is, some names of historical
characters have been omitted when describing the period of
Oligarchy Republic and the dominance of the ‘thirty
families’ as well as the period of the first Peruvian
mestizo blood president (as he mentions on pages 51-52).
For readers who have little knowledge of Peruvian society,
concrete historical references would be very illustrative.
Although John Buckley, Bishop of Cork and Ross mentions in
the Foreword of the book, that this text is the result of
O’Brien’s anecdotal recollections, the lack of bibliographic
information implies some problems with the historical
information, and for a scholarly project, the reader might
have problems verifying the collected data. For example,
when O’Brien discusses Guzmán’s capture, he mentions that
‘By coincidence, one of the detectives lived close by. On
the Saturday night of the assault on the house this man
staged a barbecue in his garden’
(206); however, there is a great deal of information that
states that the DINCOTE (Dirección Nacional contra el
terrorismo – a counter-terrorist branch of Peruvian
National Police) rented the house for this specific capture,
and all the happenings inside Guzmán’s neighbor house
(including the barbecue) were addressed to accomplish what
was known as the Victoria operation (the Shining Path
leader capture plan). On the other hand, the text does not
mention if the military coup lead by General Juan Velasco
Alvarado on 3 October 1968 (and who was in power from 1968
to1975)
had an impact on Irish missions, given the fact that this
period of time characterizes nationalization as well as a
rejection to “foreign” communities and congregations. In
addition, O’Brien’s familiarity with Peruvian culture allows
him to portray their customs and traditions vividly;
however, the text lacks careful editing of Spanish
terms.
In sum, the easy and engaging readings of
Children of the Sun: the Cork Mission to South America
allows the reader to learn of the role of the missionary
work initiated by Cork Bishop Cornelius Lucey and put into
action by Father Michael Murphy and Michael Crowley with the
support of the Mercy Order nuns and Bon Secours Sisters in
South America. The Cork and Ross Mission is a result of the
work of three Irish religious generations. They invested
money on infrastructure such as churches, schools, and
medical centers, and gave a great deal of dedication and
help to the neglected and poor Peruvian barrios such
as El Porvenir, Florencia, and Esperanza,
among others. This book is highly recommended to any reader
who is interested in learning more about the social,
political, and economic challenges the Irish mission faced
in South American countries, or in the so-called ‘Third
World’ countries. In addition, the photographs included in
the text help readers visualize O’Brien’s narrative. As this
text is about the retrieval of a memory, Peruvians that grew
up during this time period could read this book as
eye-opening experience with regards to the work of Irish
priests and nuns in the fight against poverty. In fact, they
built a bridge between two countries, two continents, and
left an important legacy on this side of the world. This
book, written from an Irish priest’s perspective,
contributes to the discussion of missionary work rarely
examined.
|